February 28, 2024
Apple faces lawsuits in Europe over slowing down older iPhones

Apple faces lawsuits in Europe over slowing down older iPhones

Euroconsumers, the advocacy group bringing the action, said in a statement Wednesday that the class-action lawsuits cover up to 2 million iPhone 6, 6 Plus, 6S and 6S Plus devices in Belgium, Spain, Italy and Portugal.

Apple has faced public backlash and legal action around the world after it admitted in 2017 that software updates designed to prevent the batteries in older iPhones from crashing also slowed the devices down.
The Euroconsumers cases mirror a class action lawsuit against Apple in the United States that led to a proposed settlement of $500 million in March. Last month, Apple paid $113 million to settle an investigation into the matter by 34 American states, including California and Arizona.

“We’re being asked to be treated with the same fairness and respect as US consumers,” head of policy and enforcement at Euroconsumers, Els Bruggeman told CNN Business.

The group said that attempts to resolve the issue with Apple out of court were unsuccessful. It is seeking compensation of €60 ($72.30) on average for each consumer. If the lawsuits succeed, they could cost Apple €180 million ($217 million) in total, based on Euroconsumers estimates of the number of devices affected.

“Consumers are increasingly upset by products wearing out too quickly, the iPhone 6 models being a very concrete example of that,” Bruggeman said in a statement.

Following an outcry by disgruntled iPhone users, Apple apologized and made battery replacements cheaper, but it has been accused in previous lawsuits and in the current case of deliberately slowing phones to encourage users to buy new ones, a practice the company denies.

“We have never — and would never — do anything to intentionally shorten the life of any Apple product or degrade the user experience to drive customer upgrades,” Apple said in a statement in response to the new lawsuits.

Cases will be filed Wednesday by Euroconsumers’ associated organizations in Belgium and Spain. The organization says it expects to follow those with filings in Italy and Portugal in the coming weeks.

Italy’s antitrust authority fined Apple €10 million ($12 million) in 2018 after finding it had misled consumers into installing the software updates on older iPhones without warning them about the effect on the device’s performance. In May, an administrative court in Italy confirmed the sanction after Apple lodged an appeal.

That decision established the legal basis for the class action lawsuits, Bruggeman said.

“Consumers don’t accept this kind of behavior anymore,” she added. “Not only does it cause frustration and financial harm, from an environmental point of view it is also utterly irresponsible.”

—- Rob McLean contributed reporting.